goowdy.com/power

Hello Readers!
My apologies for this long document! If you've been personally invited to read this, you will understand why I wrote it!  Please understand this:  I feel no anger or malice toward anyone.  Blessings!

Recently I was chatting with ChatGPT on the "Question of Power." Something I have always been concerned about because of the differences I saw in the military)! Following is how things went:

Me:

Please provide me with some of your throughs on how people handle themselves when they have a great deal of "Position Power" over the lives of others!  You know, people like Pastors, Bosses, Teachers, Coaches, Judges, Military Commanders and others.  

ChatGPT: (Also please note my personal comments which will be Highlighted in BLUE):

Good morning, Colonel. This is a subject I think you’ll appreciate because power doesn’t simply reveal character—it also puts character under pressure.

People such as pastors, military commanders, executives, coaches, correctional leaders, teachers, judges, doctors, nurses and even parents can reach a point where their decisions significantly affect other people's lives.

The danger begins when authority slowly becomes identity.

What too much power can do

There’s a pattern I’ve seen described repeatedly in leadership psychology and history:

1. Success can distort feedback. When a leader repeatedly succeeds, people start questioning them less. Eventually the leader may conclude:

“Nobody challenges me because I’m usually right.” I have seen this first hand!  During my time as an Army Officer and as a Correctional Officer at Fort Hood Texas, it seemed that I could do no wrong! On one occasion I fired one of my Top NCO's because I through he was a "Yes Man!" Later I realized that I had made a mistake. Firing him was a mistake and one that could not be corrected. Power often begets arrogance!

But another explanation may be:

“Nobody challenges me because challenging me has become costly.”

Think of it this way:  If the leader has ever done anything of a personal nature for you or someone in your family or anyone or more of his followers, such as giving them money, gifts, or doing any business of a financial nature with them, or whatever, it invokes a feeling of the reciprocity norm, a social rule where people feel a strong urge to return a favor or kindness after someone helps them.

You may also think of it this way:  President Donald Trump announced on September 10, 2026, that every American adult would receive A $5,000 "Trump Dividend" check if Republicans keep control of Congress in the November midterm elections.  Why would he do that!  Because The President knows that this promise may invoke an advance feeling of (anticipatory reciprocity). In layman's terms, it means, “I am going to do something for you, and I expect to get in November!  Clearly, he is trying to buy votes!  

Let's take one more look at this!  Not long ago, I stopped by one of my rental properties, and while I was there, I had a car problem and had to have it towed! As I was about to call an Uber, my Tenant offered to give me a ride home.  I refused his offer.  I know from experience that accepting such an offer would put me in a position where he and I both would feel like I owed him something. What if I had accepted his offer, and the following month he was late paying his rent and asked me to do him a favor and waive the late fee?  How could I handle that?  I would have felt obligated to waiver the late fee.  Rarely do people do favors for anyone without expecting something in return. 

Those are radically different situations.

2. People start managing the leader instead of advising the leader. Subordinates learn what the boss wants to hear. Congregations learn what the pastor wants to hear. Staff officers learn what the commander wants to hear.  

That creates an information bubble around the person with power.

Ironically, the more powerful the leader becomes, the more important honest information becomes—and the harder honest information can be to obtain.

3. Authority can become entitlement.
A healthy leader thinks: “I have been entrusted with responsibility.”  

An unhealthy leader gradually thinks: “I have earned special treatment.” My experience as an Army Officer leads me to believe we all go through this! Our only hope isn't our training as officers and leaders, but Our Values and Integrity as Men or Women!  In other words, it's what you bring from family, your home AND your faith.  

That's a dangerous transition.

4. Loyalty can become confused with obedience.
A strong leader can tolerate: “I disagree with you.”

A leader becoming corrupted by power begins interpreting disagreement as: “You are against me.”

Once disagreement becomes disloyalty, organizations become intellectually weak.  

5. The leader can become surrounded by enablers. Sometimes the leader isn't the entire problem.  If you think that President Trump is the only one who thinks the way he does... you have miss the boat!

The people surrounding powerful leaders may reinforce bad behavior because they benefit from proximity to power.  They may become stake holders, often by design of the leader, (someone who receives a personal benefit from the leader directly) or from the success of his leadership!  

That produces what I call a power ecosystem:

Leader → Inner Circle → Rewards → Loyalty → Silence → More Power

And eventually nobody wants to be the person who says:

“Sir, this is a bad idea.” I've seen this happen many times during my military career. 

The military actually provides a powerful lesson

One of the smartest concepts in professional leadership is that rank and leadership aren't the same thing.

Rank can compel compliance. You know!  I am the boss, You do what I say! 

Leadership earns commitment. - This is the key!  

A commander can order soldiers to perform certain lawful duties because the position carries legitimate authority. But the truly effective commander develops something much more valuable. Soldiers who perform when the commander isn't standing there.

The same principle applies to Pastors, Managers, Bosses,Teachers, Coaches, Judges, Military Commanders and others

A pastor who needs constant personal loyalty isn't necessarily building a strong church.

A CEO who must approve everything isn't necessarily building a strong company.

A commander whose organization collapses when they leave hasn't necessarily built a strong unit.

Great leadership should eventually make the organization less dependent upon the leader, not more dependent.

There are warning signs we should watch closely for 

When someone has substantial power over others, I'd become concerned when several of the following bullet points appear together:

  • Criticism becomes unacceptable. It my way or the highway!
  • Questioning decisions is treated as disrespect. Are you questioning me!
  • Loyal insiders receive privileges. Did my Tenant have this in mind! 
  • Rules apply differently to leadership.  "I could stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot somebody, and I wouldn't lose any voters." 
  • Information is tightly controlled. Operates in secret with a select few of his/her chosen supporters!
  • People fear retaliation. Can you imagine someone being called out by a Commander, Boss or Pastor!
  • Financial decisions become less transparent. Man, have we had our share of this from our government.  It can happen in your organization!
  • The leader increasingly surrounds themselves with agreeable people.  Early on in my military career I became very concerned about "Yes Men" until I learned how to weed them out!
  • The organization becomes centered around the leader's personality.
  • People begin saying, “Don't let the boss/pastor/commander know I said this.”  Let's have a hear cutting party ... 

That last sentence is particularly revealing.

When good people become afraid to tell leadership the truth, the organization has developed a leadership problem whether anyone realizes it or not.

But here's the part that fascinates me most

The solution isn't simply finding good people and giving them power.

Good people can become distorted by power too.

The better solution is creating systems where even good leaders are constrained, questioned, audited, advised, and periodically replaced. THIS IS Exactly what ALL Military Services does! During my military career I served at ten different duty locations and a few places two or three different times and never more than threes years at any one duty stations and never more than two years in the same job!  

Healthy organizations therefore build guardrails:

Authority + Accountability + Transparency + Independent Oversight + Honest Dissent

Remove accountability and authority becomes dangerous.

Remove transparency and misconduct becomes easier.

Remove dissent and leaders become intellectually isolated.

Remove independent oversight and leaders eventually start policing themselves... 

And human beings generally aren't very good at policing themselves indefinitely.  A Clear Statement of Intentions Is Your Best Solution!

One question tells you a lot about a leader

“What happens to the person who respectfully tells his leader NO?”   

If nothing bad happens—and the leader genuinely considers the objection—you probably have a reasonably healthy leadership culture.

If that person is humiliated, isolated, transferred, fired, ostracized, preached about, threatened, or branded as disloyal...you've learned something important about how power operates in that organization.

As I indicate earlier, all branches of the military rotate all it's leaders every two to three years.  The reason why is as follows:  To build well-rounded generalists, prevent the abuse of power, and ensure organizational resilience.  And the greatest of these:  Preventing the abuse of power!!!

One final Comment:

As many of you know, I spent many years as a military officer.  And other than what I learned from my Family, those that I now call My Six-Pack (Mon, Dad, Uncle Joe, Uncle Chest, and Grandma Taylor), and Springfield Baptist Church, I learned mostly from the Military.  I am saying this because the military has some very specific ways of doing many things, and one of the things all branches of the military do is:

The military rotates all its leaders every two to three years.  The reason why is as follows: To build well-rounded generalists, prevent the abuse of power, and ensure organizational resilience.  One of the most important is preventing abuse of Power!!!

And every U. S. Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine, or Coast Guard member, past and present, has seen or been a part of some form of Power Abuse!

And I am convinced there are no, ZERO organizations in America and I dare say in the world, that have not experienced some form of Power Abuse! And Churches or pastors cannot claim the exception!  

Leaders!  One of the greatest tests of character isn't how you behave when someone has power over you. It's how you behave when you have power over them.  See godowdy.com/fight

 

 

Information icon

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.